Policing is a Dirty Job, But Nobody’s Gotta Do It: 6 Ideas for a Cop-Free World

by Louis Proyect on February 22, 2015

Screen shot 2015-02-22 at 11.41.40 AM

(In this, the next to last article in a series on the new civil rights movement that arose after a series of cop killings, the editors decided to crosspost a remarkable article in the mainstream press that comes at things from the same angle as Manuel Barrera’s. This should encourage us to think that our ideas are not that far removed from ones that are becoming more and more acceptable to millions of Americans.)

After months of escalating protests and grassroots organizing in response to the police killings of Michael Brown and Eric Garner, police reformers have issued many demands. The moderates in this debate typically qualify their rhetoric with “We all know we need police, but…” It’s a familiar refrain to those of us who’ve spent years in the streets and the barrios organizing around police violence, only to be confronted by officers who snarl, “But who’ll help you if you get robbed?” We can put a man on the moon, but we’re still lacking creativity down here on Earth.

But police are not a permanent fixture in society. While law enforcers have existed in one form or another for centuries, the modern police have their roots in the relatively recent rise of modern property relations 200 years ago, and the “disorderly conduct” of the urban poor. Like every structure we’ve known all our lives, it seems that the policing paradigm is inescapable and everlasting, and the only thing keeping us from the precipice of a dystopic Wild West scenario. It’s not. Rather than be scared of our impending Road Warrior future, check out just a few of the practicable, real-world alternatives to the modern system known as policing:

  1. Unarmed mediation and intervention teams

Unarmed but trained people, often formerly violent offenders themselves, patrolling their neighborhoods to curb violence right where it starts. This is real and it exists in cities from Detroit to Los Angeles. Stop believing that police are heroes because they are the only ones willing to get in the way of knives or guns – so are the members of groups like Cure Violence, who were the subject of the 2012 documentary The Interrupters. There are also feminist models that specifically organize patrols of local women, who reduce everything from cat-calling and partner violence to gang murders in places like Brooklyn. While police forces have benefited from military-grade weapons and equipment, some of the most violent neighborhoods have found success through peace rather than war.

  1. The decriminalization of almost every crime

What is considered criminal is something too often debated only in critical criminology seminars, and too rarely in the mainstream. Violent offenses count for a fraction of the 11 to 14 million arrests every year, and yet there is no real conversation about what constitutes a crime and what permits society to put a person in chains and a cage. Decriminalization doesn’t work on its own: The cannabis trade that used to employ poor Blacks, Latinos, indigenous and poor whites in its distribution is now starting to be monopolized by already-rich landowners. That means that wide-scale decriminalization will need to come with economic programs and community projects. To quote investigative journalist Christian Parenti’s remarks on criminal justice reform in his book Lockdown America, what we really need most of all is “less.”

  1. Restorative Justice

Also known as reparative or transformative justice, these models represent an alternative to courts and jails. From hippie communes to the IRA and anti-Apartheid South African guerrillas to even some U.S. cities like Philadelphia’s experiment with community courts, spaces are created where accountability is understood as a community issue and the entire community, along with the so-called perpetrator and the victim of a given offense, try to restore and even transform everyone in the process. It has also been used uninterrupted by indigenous and Afro-descendant communities like San Basilio de Palenque in Colombia for centuries, and it remains perhaps the most widespread and far-reaching of the alternatives to the adversarial court system.

  1. Direct democracy at the community level

Reducing crime is not about social control. It’s not about cops, and it’s not a bait-and-switch with another callous institution. It’s giving people a sense of purpose. Communities that have tools to engage with each other about problems and disputes don’t have to consider what to do after anti-social behaviors are exhibited in the first place. A more healthy political culture where people feel more involved is a powerful building block to a less violent world.

  1. Community patrols

This one is a wildcard. Community patrols can have dangerous racial overtones, from pogroms to the KKK to George Zimmerman. But they can also be an option that replaces police with affected community members when police are very obviously the criminals. In Mexico, where one of the world’s most corrupt police forces only has credibility as a criminal syndicate, there have been armed groups of Policia Comunitaria and Autodefensas organized by local residents for self-defense from narcotraffickers, femicide and police. Obviously these could become police themselves and then be subject to the same abuses, but as a temporary solution they have been making a real impact. Power corrupts, but perhaps in Mexico, withering power won’t have enough time to corrupt.

  1. Here’s a crazy one: mental health care

In 2012, Mayor Rahm Emanuel closed up the last trauma clinics in some of Chicago’s most violent neighborhoods. In New York, Rikers Island jails as many people with mental illnesses “as all 24 psychiatric hospitals in New York State combined,” which is reportedly 40% of the people jailed at Rikers. We have created a tremendous amount of mental illness, and in the real debt and austerity dystopia we’re living in, we have refused to treat each other for our physical and mental wounds. Mental health has often been a trapdoor for other forms of institutionalized social control as bad as any prison, but shifting toward preventative, supportive and independent living care can help keep those most impacted from ending up in handcuffs or dead on the street.
Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/policing-is-a-dirty-job-but-nobodys-gotta-do-it-6-ideas-for-a-cop-free-world-20141216

{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

Manuel Barrera March 8, 2015 at 2:47 pm

I was heartened to read this article from the, well, erratic at times, Rolling Stone. José Martín really amplifies what ¨community control¨ might look like if any communities were to organize and build upon the mass movement against police violence. What is important about Martín´s description is how a movement for community control becomes a movement for challenging the power behind the role of the police and what needs to be done not only about creating and managing a safe and secure environment in neighborhoods–something that the existence of the current system of police clearly has not created–but also how such an organization must also address the greater, more directly responsible elements of society that have led to the conditions of oppression within oppressed communities; namely, the need to address social and economic problems owing to the profit system that makes employment contingent on whether rich people can get richer and makes education, healthcare, food, environmental protections and all the other social issues contingent on capital “control” rather human needs. Countering police occupation with decriminalization, direct democracy, restorative justice, and restoring justice to the social contract of a truly democratic society puts at center stage the people not “fighters”, democrats not “Democrats”, human intervention not a false sense of “counterinsurgency”. By creating a mass-based movement that focuses on the needs of children, youth, families, and elders to a safe and secure environment and not a counterforce of poorly armed small units against the police, creates the context in which a real conversation of how best to defend democratic rights can be undertaken. It is only in such a context that we can mobilize a significant mass-based defense that whole communities are willing to organize because it becomes our decision and our common commitment.
No one should have the illusion that such a movement or such a level organization is going to come about simply or necessarily even directly from the current movement against police violence. However, the more that any movement–whether we are speaking about Black Lives Matter, parents opting out of state education testing of their children, or in support of environmental justice–begin to realize that it is up to us to develop community and mass-based solutions counter to the state “answers” to these questions, the greater the possibility we can finally arrive at a united movement that mobilizes people as veritable counterforce against the forces that seek to keep us under occupation, both militarily and socially.

In my view, it is these kinds of discussions, education, and actions that a more united left need to be focusing upon.


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: